
Originally Posted by
Wool
I'm the same way. I like to start from the beginning, sometimes even if the beginning is bad, just to see the whole journey and see how much a thing improves. For example, I forgot to post about it here but I recently played through the old Warcraft games again and I started at Orcs & Humans despite remembering it being pretty bad.
Anyway, Last Light (the 2nd one) probably still holds up. I think I overall liked it the most. Fans will consider me a heathen, but I thought 2033 (the 1st one) was bad even back when I played it. Might still be worth playing if you want to see where it began or like dark tunnels. You spend most of your time in the Metro and the surface is basically thought to be hell, but each consecutive game spends more and more time there.
I wouldn't worry about survival mechanics. There is a bullet economy that I didn't really find that impactful and you have to manage mask filters, but that's about it. The real problem with the first one is just shoddy design. They did re-release both of the first two games in remastered "Redux" editions. I don't know if this makes 2033 any better or not, but they are pretty cheap on sale so your only real cost is time. The atmosphere is the general draw for all three of them, and each of them has a slightly different vibe.
I think Last Light is still worth playing. 2033 could be hard to go back to if you aren't prepared for frustration, but it's still just a shooter. Just don't play it on hard.