I'm surprised I didn't update this thread lately, because dayum it's been bad.
Late April 2014, after my fiancee got home from a weekend in NYC for a friend's birthday, we decided to go to a different, brand new Red Robin location right near the bus stop.
We both got food poisoning again within the time it took us to drive home and lost a few days' work from it.
We've limited ourselves to two-a-month "fuck it" dinners - one eating out, one take-out/delivery.
Our eating out option tends to be a local Chinese buffet, and it's usually quite good.
One of those days back in March 2015 we returned to a local Italian place for our third visit.
The first time we'd gone the food was amazing.
The second time was underwhelming.
The third time simply sucked. We won't be going back.
Outback seems to be a consistently good choice.
The first of two remaining local BBQ places has (as I've mentioned in this thread before) simply gone way down hill with regards to their pulled pork quality, and they don't even give you corn mini-muffins anymore. Instead you get a small 1.5" cube of corn bread (likely made in a huge sheet pan, given the pile out of which I saw them dig it.) I haven't even bothered trying anything else from there.
Our go-to quality sushi place is as awesome as ever (we went for Valentine's, and even though we were freezing our balls off in their second floor banquet area due to heavy traffic) we can't wait to go back.
(I'd had more examples mentally listed but they've all been wiped out since I spent the last two hours at a coworker's desk trying to remove malware. Sigh.)